Consumer ProtectionLaw Group
Consumer Protection Law Group
Consumer Protection Law Group
You just bought a new (or new-to-you) car, eager for smooth drives and trouble-free rides. Now, however, you’re more frequently visiting the mechanic than the grocery store. Frustrating, isn’t it? If your car repeatedly develops significant issues that can’t be fixed by the manufacturer or dealer, you might be dealing with a “lemon.” But how do you know if your vehicle actually qualifies under California’s Lemon Law?
In this article, we will break down what makes up a lemon in California, your consumer rights, and how you can proceed to get the compensation or replacement that you deserve. Whether you have engine issues, brake problems, or electrical terrors, having the law on your side can help you navigate your way out of trouble.
California’s Lemon Law exists for one simple reason: to protect you from getting stuck with a car that just doesn’t work the way it should, even after repeated trips to the dealership. At its heart is the Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act, a powerful law designed to hold automakers accountable when they sell lemon cars.
This legislation states that if your new (or in certain instances used) vehicle continues to have major issues — and the manufacturer is unable to repair it after a reasonable number of attempts — then they are legally bound to replace the vehicle or refund your money.
But it gets even better in California.
This is the essence of California’s Lemon Law. It protects vehicles bought or leased within the state, and a broad spectrum of ailments, if the vehicle still has the original factory warranty.
So, if your engine keeps stalling or the transmission refuses to cooperate, if those problems truly impact use, value, or safety of the vehicle, and the dealer is unable to remedy them within a reasonable time frame, you could have a lemon.
This is the play-by-play rulebook for when a car officially becomes a lemon. It provides a “presumption” in the sense that, in certain situations, the law presumes the automobile is a lemon unless the manufacturer can establish otherwise. Examples include:
If any of those sound familiar, that presumption applies — and you may not have to work as hard to prove your claim.
There’s also a federal lemon law, the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act, but California’s is much more consumer-friendly and powerful. Whereas the federal law can be applied in general warranty disputes, California’s Lemon Law is more specific, has clear remedies, and even requires manufacturers to pay your attorney’s fees if you succeed with your case. That’s to say, you can often battle your claim without a second thought about what it will cost.
Before you progress too far with a Lemon Law claim, you should first find out if your vehicle is covered at all under California regulations. The good news: The legislation covers a wide range of cars, trucks, and SUVs — new and, in many cases, used — as long as certain requirements are fulfilled.
Let’s break it down:
If you bought or leased a new car, truck, SUV, or van in California for personal, household, or family use, your vehicle likely qualifies. So do most recreational or commuting use vehicles. As long as the problems happen within the manufacturer’s original warranty period, you qualify.
California’s Lemon Law even applies to used cars, but there is one huge exception:
The vehicle must remain under the initial manufacturer’s factory warranty or be a Certified Pre-Owned (CPO) vehicle supported by a manufacturer’s warranty when you bought it.
So, if you just bought a used vehicle from a dealer and it came with a manufacturer’s warranty on it, breathe easy. That coverage provides a window for lemon law protection, even if you are not the first owner.
Own a small business? The law might still affect you. Lemon Law protection applies to commercial vehicles if:
This protects small business owners from being left in the lurch if the company car they purchased is a lemon.
Not all cars are eligible. The following are excluded under California Lemon Law:
So if you lifted your truck, installed a turbo kit, or neglected your oil changes, don’t look for lemon protection to save the fallout.
Just because your car is not functioning properly does not always automatically qualify it as a lemon under California law. To technically qualify, your car will need to meet three significant criteria.
Let’s take a closer look at each requirement:
This is not a matter of a loose radio dial or noisy brakes. For a car to be considered a lemon, it must have a substantial defect that impairs one or more of the following:
Some common examples of serious defects are:
Cosmetic blemishes or minor issues (like a creaky seat or wonky A/C) don’t generally qualify — unless they are the symptom of an overall, recurrent issue.
California’s Lemon Law doesn’t necessarily entail that your car has to be in total operable condition, but it does mean the manufacturer must have made a good effort to fix it. The law establishes what “reasonable” is under the Tanner Consumer Protection Act, and the criteria are very specific.
Here’s when a car will be considered a lemon in California:
Note that these rules expire within the initial 18 months or 18,000 miles of taking delivery of the car — whichever is sooner. However, cars beyond that period are still eligible under Lemon Law but with additional evidence and legal guidance required.
Also, occasionally manufacturers will try to assert a defect is not “substantial” or will try to blame user error — so it is worth it to keep a record of every visit to the service center, dates, description of defect, and length of out-of-service time.
This is where some vehicle owners unknowingly disqualify themselves. Only repairs done by the manufacturer or its authorized dealerships count toward Lemon Law eligibility.
That means:
Why? Because the law must provide the producer every opportunity to get it right through its authorized service facilities. Where they can’t get it right — that’s when Lemon Law protections come in.
So if you’re seeing repeat repairs, stick with your dealership, request detailed service reports, and keep a folder of all communications, work orders, and repair invoices. These will be valuable evidence in case you need to file a claim or get the advice of an attorney.
If your car is a lemon according to California’s Lemon Law, you have a series of important rights that can help you in getting the remedy or compensation you deserve. These rights are designed to make sure that consumers are not stuck with defective cars. This is an overview of what you deserve:
One of the most common outcomes when a car qualifies as a lemon is that you can return the vehicle to the manufacturer and get a buyback. This means you’ll be reimbursed for:
However, the company can deduct a mileage adjustment — a sum of money proportional to what percent of the worth of the automobile you have traveled prior to when the flaw started to become obvious. Essentially, the more wear you’ve accumulated on the car, the lower refund you’ll receive.
Please bear in mind that the repurchase amount is the full cost of ownership and is to place you where you would have been if you had bought the defective car.
Alternatively to a refund, you are eligible to receive a replacement vehicle. If you choose to do so, the manufacturer is required to offer you a new car that is substantially identical to the one that you purchased. This includes the same make and model, having the same features, so you don’t lose any value from the original purchase.
The replacement vehicle should be free from defects and come with a new warranty. In some cases, you could also get an extension of the warranty to cover any time you spent using the defective car.
If the manufacturer knowingly and willfully violated the Lemon Law by failing to uphold the buyback or replacement policy, the court can impose civil penalties. The penalties could be as much as twice the vehicle’s value. Essentially, if the manufacturer’s behavior was especially egregious or fraudulent, they can be fined money in addition to having to compensate you.
This is a provision to motivate manufacturers to behave in good faith and comply with the law. It’s also a way of making them accountable for their actions if they try to avoid their Lemon Law responsibility.
One of the most buyer-friendly features of California’s Lemon Law is that the manufacturer is required to cover your attorney costs if you win your case. This is significant because it guarantees that you won’t have to worry about costly legal fees when pursuing a claim. The manufacturer will cover the cost of this, so you can more easily seek legal counsel without it being as expensive for you.
This provision is important because it encourages consumers to pursue court action without fear of paying the hefty fees typically associated with hiring an attorney. In fact, it’s part of the reason why so many people choose to hire the services of an attorney to navigate the Lemon Law for them, because they know they won’t have to pay out of pocket if they are successful.
California’s Lemon Law is a valuable legal remedy intended to protect consumers from being stuck with lemon vehicles. If your vehicle has significant flaws affecting its use, safety, or value, and the maker hasn’t made a reasonable amount of repairs, you may be entitled to a buyback, replacement, or even reimbursement for the hassle.
If you believe your vehicle can be considered a lemon, don’t wait to contact the professionals. Consumer Protection Law Group has successfully resolved more than 3,915 cases across the country and is ready to assist you in getting the compensation you are entitled to. With no advance fees, you can concentrate on putting your life together while we battle for you. Call us today to arrange a complimentary consultation and discover how we may assist you with your Lemon Law case.
$26,534
$24,110
$23,345
$23,000
$22,195
$22,000
$21,586
$21,550
$20,183
$20,000
$20,000
$19,411
$18,000
$18,000
$17,000
$16,000
Consumer Protection
Call (424) 677-1115